Originally Posted by heron
The current wars have no corner on emotional trauma. Shell shock was a real psych diagnosis after the first and second world wars ... after korea and vietnam, it became pstd ... put that together with the less than nurturing social structure of the military (they're soldiers, after all ... not teachers or social workers or nurses) are we really surprised at the suicide rates?
I agree that it's shameful that our soldiers can be so deeply damaged and be unable to get help when they need it. It's shameful when a career military person has to go on food stamps because she/he can't support a family on military pay. At the height of the pro-war hysteria after 9/11, people were accused of treason and lack of support for our troops for criticizing the war. At the very same time, a young man joined the army and collected a bonus for doing so. He was wounded and lost an arm within a few months of being deployed to Iraq. He was medically discharged from the army and the government wanted him to give back the bonus!!!
When he couldn't, they dinged his credit report!
The nature of war and the work our soldiers are called upon to do isn't going to change ... it can't.
What's shameful is that the men and women who do that work are left twisting in the wind when we're done using them.
Shameful and immoral.
I am in complete agreement. I am fairly anti-war myself, but as you can tell, I am the very proud sister of a Marine. You are right - war is what it is, and whether it was 1776, 1917, 1944, or 2005, no matter what side you're on, it will always be gory, bloody, sad. And our best will always come home changed.
I think your last couple paragraphs are what nail it for me - we use them and abuse them, then when they're too crippled or too insane to be any good at fighting, we drop them. That is what bothers me. (And by 'we', I mean the country's government.)
My stepfather was WW2 infantry. He spent 6mo in a VA hospital after coming back to the States in '45. By all accounts he has lived a full life - successful business, a family that is crazy about him, and an abiding faith. But he still won't talk much about the war, 60+ years later. He won't talk about why he spent that time in the hospital. He refuses to go back there. The captain directly above him, he watched get KIA on Okinawa. Dad wrote the citation for the captain's Congressional Medal of Honor, which he got posthumously. Only recently did he go to the WW2 memorial in Charleston and when he found his buddy's name, cried like a baby. At 90 years old.
Sorry for going off on this tangent. It just breaks my heart that there is so little for these men (and women) when they come home.
World News & Politics